The Supreme Court (SC) has junked a new administrative complaint against dismissed Pasig City Regional Trial Court (RTC) Branch 167 Judge Rolando Mislang.
In a recent 10-page decision, the SC 2nd Division rejected the Office of the Court Administrator’s (OCA) finding that Mislang violated Canon 2 of the Code of Judicial Conduct when he lifted an asset seizure order without waiting for the complainant to air his side.
Mislang on May 28, 2012 issued a seizure order on the Armed Forces of the Philippines’ (AFP) payment deposited in the bank account of medical supplier Ruth Bautista, whom Philip See accused of failing to pay for the X-ray machines she bought from him.
The judge on May 22, 2013 quashed his earlier order, after Bautista successfully argued that the payments were still public funds under the AFP because of a lack of certificate of final acceptance.
Mislang had not waited for See to file his comment or opposition to Bautista’s motion to quash when he granted it.
This prompted See to file an administrative complaint accusing Mislang of depriving him of due process. The OCA issued a recommendation in favor of See.
However, the SC said Mislang correctly lifted the seizure order because it had been prematurely granted. It noted that it was illegal to garnish the funds due to a private entity if it was still in the possession of the government.
The SC also said See was not denied his right to due process. It even faulted the complainant for failing to attend the hearing on Bautista’s motion to quash and abide by the order to file a comment within five days of the hearing.
It also took exception to See’s reasoning that he filed an administrative complaint because It was “utterly useless and highly impractical” to appeal Mislang’s order.
“An administrative complaint against a judge is not a substitute for a proper remedy taken in due course to review and undo his or her acts or omissions done in the performance of judicial duties and functions,” read the decision penned by Associate Justice Antonio Carpio.
The SC already dismissed Mislang from service on July 26, 2016, in connection with his repeated issuance of injunctions stopping the Department of Justice’s (DOJ) preliminary investigation against Globe Asiatique Realty Holdings Corporation president Delfin Lee.
But, it did not actually render See’s complaint moot and academic since the SC could have imposed a fine on Mislang had it ruled favorably.