The Sandiganbayan Third Division denied former Sen. Ramon “Bong” Revilla Jr.’s motion for reconsideration insisting on the inhibition of Associate Justice Karl Miranda from his malversation case stemming from his alleged receipt of kickbacks from a flood control project.
Miranda, Chairperson of the anti-graft court’s Third Division, was the lone justice who voted against the grant of bail to Revilla.
In seeking Miranda’s recusal from the case, Revilla said Miranda’s brother acted as a lawyer for former Public Works Undersecretary Roberto Bernardo and had cited Bernardo’s statements in his separate opinion disagreeing with the bail grant.
He also said Miranda made remarks about Good Conduct Time Allowance (GCTA) that gave the impression that he may have prejudged the case.
But in its resolution, the Third Division said the circumstances Revilla cited do not create the impression that Miranda cannot rule on the case impartially.
Mere suspicion or imputation of bias is not enough, it said.
“Hence, unjustified assumptions and mere misgivings cannot overcome the presumption that a judge shall decide on the merits of a case with an unclouded vision of its facts,” it said.
It noted that Revilla’s arguments suggest that Miranda could only correctly resolve the case by not giving any merit to Bernardo’s testimony, but it said that this was not reasonable or fair when it comes to assessing the appearance of impartiality.
It also said Miranda’s brother or his law firm has not appeared in this case, and Bernardo himself is not a party to the case.
Turning Bernardo into a state witness is also out of the court’s hands as it is up to the discretion of the Ombudsman and the Department of Justice, it added.
The Sandiganbayan also said a reasonable observer would not attribute Miranda’s vote to deny bail to his brother, and would instead consider that his separate opinion included citations of testimonies of other witnesses and documentary evidence.
It stressed that adverse rulings, by themselves, do not prove bias or partiality warranting inhibition.
“In this case, Justice Miranda has already shown that his Separate Opinion is based on a thorough analysis of all the evidence presented by the prosecution, and thus, it cannot be simply disregarded as evidence of bias or prejudice,” it said.
As for Miranda’s GCTA remark, the court said a reasonable observer would know of Miranda’s long advocacy for persons deprived of liberty and that there are provisions in the GCTA law that could provide benefits for those preventively imprisoned. Thus, his remarks could not be considered a prejudgment of the case.