Para magkaalaman na! Ex-CJ Panganiban says SC Justices’ monthly loads, output should be made public
Fed up with the Supreme Court’s chronic delay in resolving cases, former Chief Justice Artemio Panganiban is proposing to have a public tally of the each Justice’s output every month.
Panganiban believed this would allow the public to know who among the magistrates were hardworking and diligent and those who were lazy and apathetic.
“While some justices have worked diligently to dispose of the cases raffled to them, some others have obviously not done their part,” said Panganiban in a column in the Inquirer.
“Perhaps, a little transparency to show the load ‘assigned’ to each justice and his/her monthly outputs by minute resolutions and signed decisions should be made public, so this odious lament of ‘justice delayed is justice denied’ can be supplanted with ‘prompt at last’,” he added.
The superlawyer also lamented the violation of another constitutional provision mandating that decisions
Panganiban has long “bewailed the insidious plague of delayed justice” which he noted, in some cases, was a violation of the Constitution mandating that all decisions “must be decided or resolved within twenty-four months from the date of submission.”
The SC’s backlog has ballooned to 14,491 cases as of Dec. 31, 2016 or 65 percent higher from 8,741 in 2007. Panganiban said nearly a quarter of these cases or 3,201 have breached the 24-month constitutional deadline.
Panganiban was hopeful that Chief Justice Lucas P. Bersamin’s successor (he is set to retire on October 18) would consider implementing Justice Antonio T. Carpio’s 2007 proposal “which called for a limitation of the cases that it should accept, and a disposition by minute resolution of petitions that, on their face, do not deserve review (they raise no novel question, merely reiterate old doctrines, show no grave abuse of discretion, etc).”