Solicitor General Darlene Berberabe said the government is likely to raise the issue of possible judicial overreach when it seeks partial reconsideration and clarification of the Supreme Court decision that had voided earlier budget increases and provisions in the 2026 budget related to unprogrammed appropriations.
Berberabe said the Office of the Solicitor General wants clarification of the aspects of the decision imposing guardrails prescribed for the exercise of budgetary powers.
Berberabe said there is a difference between safeguards required by the Constitution and those that are within the powers of Congress and the Executive to lay down.
“Ang amin lamang pong gustong idiin at hilingin na repasuhin nila, baka po may mga guardrails na dapat ay ipaubaya na lamang doon sa dalawang branches which are the political branches—ibig sabihin po ng political branches ito po ay Kongreso at Presidente na inihalal po ng ating taumbayan,” she said in a Palace press briefing.
She noted that the executive was given the power to propose the budget and Congress has the power to identify the priorities.
She said the executive and legislative branches should be allowed to “self-correct,” as it had done so in crafting the 2026 budget following questions raised in previous years.
“Kaya po iyon iyong sinasabi namin, na tutal sa kanila ibinigay ng Konstitusyon iyong kapangyarihan, hayaan mo silang mag-self-correct,” she said.
Measures are underway to improve the budget process, she noted.
“Marami rin pong naka-pending na mga batas, na mga bills sa Congress, iyong Budget Modernization Bill – so, nandodoon po nakapaloob lahat ho ng pinag-usapan namin doon sa oral arguments: ano ba dapat iyong deficit level, ano iyong level dapat ng unprogrammed appropriations, so para ho hindi na kumawala kagaya po noong 2024,” she added.
She said the OSG will challenge the finding that Special Provision 1(a), Chapter XLIII of the 2026 budget was unconstitutional.
The provision allows the release of unprogrammed appropriations when there are excess collections from identified non-tax revenue sources.
But the SC said unprogrammed funds should be released only when revenues exceed the overall revenue targets in the national budget, rather than when there is an excess from just one revenue source.
Berberabe said the OSG’s position is that this provision does not necessarily violate the Constitution, which gives Congress the power to prepare the form, content, and manner of the budget.
She said the President proposed Special Provision 1(a) because he knows what would trigger the unprogrammed appropriations, and this was approved by Congress according to its constitutional power.
“So, iyon po ay isa naming idudulog na, ‘Uy, wala namang nakalagay sa Konstitusyon na standard at kumbaga si Supreme Court ay nag-interpret ng isang provision of law in the GAA [General Appropriations Act], not a constitutional provision,” she said.
The SC decision had struck down as unconstitutional Congress’ P449.5-billion increase in 2024 unprogrammed appropriations and P17.99-billion hike in the 2025 DPWH Special Road Fund, ruling that both exceeded the President’s proposed spending.
The SC also voided 2026 budget provisions allowing the release of unprogrammed appropriations without sufficient safeguards.