Former law dean Mel Sta. Maria said the prosecution’s decision to drop three of four articles of impeachment against Vice President Sara Duterte benefits her legal position because it reduces the number of charges she has to fight.
Speaking on BNC’s MEMO with Korina, Sta. Maria also said defense can even capitalize on this move by the prosecution instead of appearing “rattled.”
Sta. Maria made the statement when asked about the concern that Duterte was deprived of the opportunity to counter the evidence already presented in the dropped charges and project her innocence and preserve her popularity.
“Nakasalalay sa kanila kung papaano nilang i-e-exploit ang sitwasyon. Kasi basta’t ikaw ay mukhang na-rattle, eh parang hindi mo na kino-control ang narrative kung na-rattle ka, kung ikaw ay isang abogada. Dapat i-capitalize nila ito at exploit nila ‘yung tinanggal sa sub judice at sinasabi, sabihin nila, ‘We told you so!’” Sta. Maria said.
He said the defense has to control the narrative and show that it has not been pushed off balance.
“Kaya lang ang problema, nakita natin bigla silang parang na-rattle, kasi kung may equanimity ka, pino-project mo ang iyong confidence, pero kung na-ra-rattle ka, na-a-agitate ka kaagad, pino-project mo ang iyong vulnerability, para bang isang ganun lang pala eh, it takes only that one one click to throw you off balance, ‘no? Hindi magandang tignan ‘yung, they have to capitalize ngayon,” he said.
According to him, any lawyer would be happy if charges against his or her client are dropped, as this means they no longer have to make the effort to disprove the claims.
It baffles him why the defense is bucking the prosecution’s move.
“Parang para lang sa akin, isang kabalintunaan na ikaw ay parang gusto mo pa kung gustong ibalik ‘yung mga [article] 1, 3, and 4, parang gusto mo muling ilagay sa alanganin ang iyong kliyente o si VP Sara Duterte. Tapos na nga, eh, tapos na. Pero pag ibalik mo ‘yan, eh ‘di meron uling tatlo pang pagkakataon na mahatulan siya, ito isa na lang,” he said.
“Kaya kung titingnan mong malalim, this is for the benefit of VP Sara Duterte, three fourths ang nawala sa kanilang pasisinungalingan,” he added.
Sta. Maria also said he sees no due process violation in the dropping of the three charges.
In a separate Facebook post, he explained that due process protects the respondent from a conviction without a fair trial and gives her a meaningful opportunity to defend herself against active claims.
But when the charges are withdrawn, then there is no threat of conviction over these charges, he said.
“Due Process does not guarantee a forum for the presentation of evidence that no longer carry any legal consequence,” he said.
He also said the withdrawal gave her the ultimate legal remedy, which is relief from potential conviction or removal from office based on the three charges.