Lead defense counsel Sheila Sison said the prosecution’s decision to drop three articles of impeachment and focus only on unexplained wealth should not stop the defense from presenting evidence to rebut allegations already made before the court.
Sison said it would not be fair to let allegations already made to remain unanswered.
“In other words, the prosecution would thus retain the benefit of having its evidence heard, while the respondent would be at risk of being denied the benefit of having that evidence contradicted, and we feel, and we believe that this is not, fairness, and it is not in keeping with the guarantees of due process,” she said.
She said the prosecution cannot unilaterally determine how the defense will proceed, which accusations the judges may hear, and which accusations the respondent may be permitted to answer.
“Because to allow this would be to confer upon the prosecution the extraordinary and impermissible power to control not only the presentation of its own case, but also the scope and substance of the defense case,” she said.
Sison also said that if the withdrawal is intended to shorten the proceedings of the case or of the presentation of Duterte’s evidence so that the court could proceed to judgment, “then we believe that the resulting process would bear the unmistakable characteristics of a mistrial.”
“We have spent government resources, time, energy of this court and of all participants in this trial, presenting so called evidence and hearing testimonial evidence from the witnesses that the prosecution had chosen to present before this honorable court. And yet, the defense would now appear to be forced to limit its presentation or its rebuttal to those evidence, to whatever it is, that the prosecution had decided to retain in the articles of impeachment. This, we will never allow,” she said.
She said that while the prosecution has the prerogative to withdraw articles of impeachment, this is not the power to suppress its rebuttal on the part of the respondent.
“The authority to streamline or to achieve speed in a trial is not the authority to diminish due process or to altogether disregard fundamental rules of fairness. And the desire to reach a verdict expeditiously can never justify reaching it unfairly,” she said.