Mamayang Liberal party-list Rep. Leila De Lima called for accountability as she pointed out that the Supreme Court ruling that struck down unconstitutional increases in the 2024 and 2025 budgets has not shut the door on the criminal and administrative liability of those behind the funding, unless they are found to have acted in good faith.
The SC struck down Congress’ P449.5-billion increase in unprogrammed appropriations in the 2024 national budget and its P17.99-billion hike in the Department of Public Works and Highways’ Special Road Fund in 2025, saying these exceeded the spending proposed by the President.
In doing so, the SC also said the doctrine of operative fact applies, but only to irreversible programs whose beneficiaries acted in good faith based on the presumed validity of the funding.
“However, this protection does not extend to the authors, proponents, and implementors of the aforementioned laws. These officials remain subject to criminal, civil, and administrative liability unless the proper tribunals explicitly find that they acted in good faith,” the court said in the decision penned by Senior Associate Justice Marvic Leonen.
De Lima stressed that the application of the doctrine of operative fact is not a “get-out-of-jail-free card” and called for accountability for those behind schemes related to unprogrammed appropriation if they acted in bad faith.
“Hindi dapat palusutin at palampasin ang mga abusadong pinapaikutan ang ating batas para gatasan at limasin ang kaban ng bayan,” she said.
She also called the decision a significant win in the fight for transparency and accountability in the use of public funds.
In declaring the increase in the unprogrammed appropriations unconstitutional, the SC said Congress “severely distorted” the budget and created “artificial” fiscal space that allowed increases in the other items.
“Congress’s actions, undertaken without transparency, distorted the integrity of the Budget and undermined the tedious budget preparation process,” it said.
The SC, in the same decision, said unprogrammed appropriations are not unconstitutional per se, but they must have clear limits and safeguards to preserve fiscal discipline, transparency, and accountability.
It also said they cannot include lump sums and that new or additional government revenues should generally fund programmed expenditures, unless there are clear and convincing reasons to include them under unprogrammed appropriations.
De Lima, who was among the petitioners against unprogrammed appropriations, said she had hoped for them to be abolished since she views them as an “undue delegation of legislative power to the Executive.”
Nevertheless, she said she is thankful to the SC for setting clear constitutional limits for the unprogrammed appropriations, which make it clear that this is not a “slush fund.”
“The Court has put it back in its proper place. Ang pasyang ito ng Korte Suprema ay babala sa mga nagsasabwatan at nagbabalak pang abusuhin ang UA para sa pansarili at pampulitikang interes,” she said.
She said unprogrammed appropriations had been growing out of control and used as a “holding area for pork” where lawmakers parked funds for their pet projects.
“The Supreme Court has now closed that backdoor,” she added.