The Court of Tax Appeals has ruled in favor of Petron Corp. by ordering the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) to refund or issue tax credit certificates amounting to a total of P69.58 million representing excise taxes erroneously paid on alkylate imports in February and May 2018.
In the August 14 decision penned by Associate Justice Maria Rowena Modesto-San Pedro, the court’s Second Division found that Petron’s payments of excise taxes on its alkylate importations were erroneous and illegal.
Court records showed that Petron Corp. had filed two separate petitions, later consolidated by the court, seeking the refund of excise taxes.
The company argued that alkylate, used solely as a blending component in gasoline production, should not be subject to excise tax under Sections 148(f) and (e) of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC).
Petron also contended that the BIR’s imposition of excise taxes on both the finished gasoline and the imported alkylate constituted double taxation.
The BIR, however, maintained that alkylate, being a product of distillation similar to naphtha, was subject to excise tax under Section 148(e) of the NIRC.
It argued that the law did not differentiate between primary and secondary distillation products in imposing the tax and asserted that claims for tax refunds should be strictly construed against claimants.
In its decision, the court said the company’s importation of alkylate was not subject to excise tax, citing evidence, including certifications and customs payment receipts, confirming that Petron had paid the amounts for which it sought refunds.
“The imposition of excise taxes was illegal, insofar as it was made upon property not subject to such tax and finds no basis in the relevant provisions of law,” the court ruled.
The court ordered the BIR to refund or issue tax credit certificates to Petron Corp. amounting to P34,536,789.00 for the excise taxes paid on the February 2018 importation, and P35,046,886.00 for the excise taxes paid on the May 2018 importation.