The Court of Appeals (CA) has dismissed the appeal of oil giant Petron Corporation to nullify the entirety of the Manila Comprehensive Land Use Plan and Zoning Regulations of 2006, which led to the closure of the Pandacan oil depot.
In an 18-page decision, the CA 2nd Division upheld the Manila Regional Trial Court (RTC) Branch 41’s August 2012 decision which only voided Section 55 of Ordinance Number 8119, while sustaining the validity of the rest of the zoning plan’s provisions.
The sole provision stricken out of the land use plan pertained to the imposition of a 10-meter easement from the existing shoreline and river bank to be maintained as a linear park. This was found to be in conflict with the Water Code of the Philippines’ provision for a 3-meter easement in urban areas.
Petron had wanted the entire ordinance nullified because it reclassified the now-dismantled Pandacan oil depot into a “High Density Residential/Mixed Use Zone (R3/MXD),” from the former designation of “Industrial II Zone.”
The rezoning of the depot meant Petron, as well as Pilipinas Shell Petroleum Corporation and Chevron Philippines, Inc., could no longer use the depot for their storage facilities and distribution terminals.
Petron in its appeal argued the ordinance should be invalidated because the Manila government failed to submit it to the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (MMDA) and the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board (HLURB). The oil giant also argued the city usurped the national government’s responsibility over the petroleum industry.
The CA, however, agreed with the RTC that the Manila City Council validly exercised its legislative power in coming up with the ordinance.
Although Petron presented a May 30, 2006 letter by then-Commissioner Jesus Yap Pang stating HLURB could not commit to a review of the proposed zoning plan due to the non-submission of documents, the CA said this did not categorically state that the city failed to comply with the proper procedures in enacting the ordinance.
The CA added that nothing in the laws vesting authority on the Secretary of Energy to regulate the storage of petroleum products stripped the local government units of their power to enact ordinances.
The court also declared Ordinance Number 8119 was neither unfair or oppressive nor partial or discriminatory.
“It did not prohibit, but merely regulated trade, and appellant Petron was free to engage in its business on the condition that appellant Petron observed the appellee City’s land use plans and zoning classifications,” the decision pointed out.
The court also noted that if the rest of a questioned law is “free from the taint of unconstitutionality, then it should remain in force and effect” even if one provision is stricken down. This was the point out of the separability clause in laws.
The ruling, penned by Associate Justice Nina G. Antonio-Valenzuela, also stressed that “the City Council of the appellee City was in the best position to determine the needs of its constituents.”
The depot was established in 1914, with Shell being the first to use the land. After the September 11, 2001 attacks, the Manila city government under former Mayor Lito Atienza sought the removal of the depot out of fear it could be a terrorist target.
The specific provisions of the zoning ordinance reclassifying Pandacan was initially repealed through Ordinance Number 8187 under the administration of Mayor Alfredo Lim.
However, the Supreme Court in November 2014 declared the said ordinance unconstitutional, reinstating the zoning plan’s classification of the depot as residential and mixed-use zone. The depot was dismantled in 2015.