The Court of Appeals has declared invalid the suspension of Arthur Casanova as chair of the Komisyon sa Wikang Filipino in 2022, saying this was unconstitutional as the members of the commission have no powers to discipline a presidential appointee.
The CA Special Seventh Division also said Casanova was denied due process because he was suspended by KWF commissioners without any formal charge filed against him.
Casanova was suspended based on a resolution signed by KWF Commissioners Benjamin Mendillo Jr. and Carmelita Abdurahman after he supposedly failed to call and preside over meetings of the KWF.
The Manila regional trial court subsequently dismissed Casanova’s petition questioning his suspension for failure to exhaust administrative remedies.
But in a February 28, 2024 decision, the CA reversed the RTC ruling and said Casanova has enough basis to go to the courts because of the legal question of who has the authority to suspend him.
The CA ruled that the KWF commissioners have no authority to suspend Casanova, as this power is lodged with the President since the commission chair is a presidential appointee.
“Their act of suspending him is an unconstitutional intrusion into the constitutional appointment power of the President,” the CA said.
It also pointed out that the commission’s charter places it directly under the Office of the President.
The President’s powers under the constitution to appoint officials give him full discretion to remove his appointees, it said.
“Unless otherwise provided by the Constitution, such concomitant power of the appointing authority to remove cannot be attenuated by allowing even his alter ego to discipline and worse, to remove the former’s appointee, lest the executive department would be put into a precarious situation where the very person particularly chosen by the President will be removed by his own subordinate without his prior express conformity,” it said.
The CA also said the KWF commissioners committed a “procedural faux pas” when they resorted to a shortcut in the administrative process by suspending Casanova without a preliminary investigation, a show cause order, and a formal charge against him.
“Such wanton disregard of the proper procedure in administrative investigations cannot be countenanced,” it said.
Without the investigation and formal, charge, it said Casanova did not get the chance to sufficiently defend himself. Plus, the commission and the CA could not have the chance to reasonably ascertain the truth of the allegations against him, it added.
It said the invalidation of his suspension would result in the payment of the back salaries for the period when he was suspended.
The decision was penned by Associate Justice Edwin Sorongon. Concurring were Associate Justices Ruben Reynaldo Roxas and Alfonso Ruiz II.