Dealing a blow to the government’s attempt to crack down on the duopoly in the telecommunications industry, the Court of Appeals (CA) has ordered the Philippine Competition Commission (PCC) to effectively approve the P69.1-billion buyout of San Miguel Corporation’s (SMC) telecommunications assets.
In a recent 54-page decision, the CA Former 12th Division granted the petitions of PLDT Inc. and Globe Telecom, Inc., against the PCC requirement to review the deal first before giving its approval.
This makes permanent the August 2016 writ of preliminary injunction stopping PCC from “conducting further proceedings for the pre-acquisition review and/or investigation of the subject acquisition.”
PLDT and Globe wanted to bind PCC to its “transitory rules,” issued before the implementing rules and regulations of the Philippine Competition Act came out, which “deemed approved” the two telco giants’ buyout announced in May 2016.
At the time, the transitory rules only required the telco giants to “notify” the antitrust regulator.
The CA said the PCC “cannot whimsically disregard” the transitory rules still in effect when Globe and PLDT announced the deal.
“By not following its own rules and regulations, PCC committed grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction,” read the decision penned by Associate Justice Ramon Bato.
The court added that PCC cannot unilaterally review the deal because it was the National Telecommunications Commission (NTC) that has the technical expertise to allocate frequencies to telecom companies.
“The PCC certainly has no authority to review, reverse or modify the NTC decision,” it pointed out.