The Court of Appeals denied a former Citra Metro Manila Tollways Corporation official’s petition to annul Regional Trial Court orders canceling his passport and deeming him to have waived his right to cross-examine witnesses in his estafa case filed by San Miguel Holdings Corporation.
The petition was filed by former Citra official and lawyer Alvin Bugtas, who is one of the respondents in the estafa case that also includes Indonesian businessman Shadik Wahono.
The Mandaluyong City Regional Trial Court issued the orders against Bugtas and several of his co-accused who are out on bail after they failed to heed a directive to appear before the court.
It stemmed from the prosecution’s motion to cancel Bugtas’ bail bond after one of the private prosecutors alleged that he was seen in Singapore without having acquired court permission to travel. The prosecution said Bugtas was deemed to have jumped bail.
The Mandaluyong RTC ruled that all accused, except one, waived their right to cross-examine the remaining prosecution witnesses.
It also said the trial would be conducted in absentia and directed the concerned agencies to cancel the passport of Bugtas and another co-accused.
Bugtas challenged the RTC orders, saying they violated his fundamental and constitutional rights to be represented by counsel and to confront the witnesses presented against him.
He said his absence at the trial could at most be considered a waiver of his right to be personally present. He said that since he has posted bail and has been arraigned, his presence is no longer necessary.
But the CA Special Eleventh Division, in a decision penned by Associate Justice Mary Josephine Lazaro, upheld the RTC and said Bugtas’ own actions led to the orders when he did not heed the directives to appear before the court.
“Even more, since Bugtas is a lawyer by profession, he of all people should have known that upon posting bail, there are mandatory conditions that must be unconditionally adhered to,” it added.
It said he cannot invoke his waiver of his right to attend the hearing to justify his non-appearance, since he was specifically directed to attend the hearing. He can waive his right, but not his obligation to the court, it said.
The CA said that by violating the mandatory conditions of his bail, he is deemed to have now lost his standing in court unless he surrenders again to avail himself of judicial relief.
It also noted that the certification of Bugtas’ petition was executed in Zion, Illinois, which showed his “perversity to continuously evade the Rules and conditions pertaining to his bail.”
“Ultimately, the valid declaration of trial in absentia, coupled with Bugtas’ jumping bail and his fleeing to another country are sufficient grounds for the RTC to issue the assailed orders,” it said.
It also said the waiver of Bugtas’ right to cross-examine prosecution witnesses extends to his counsel.
It further said Bugtas cannot get relief from the court when he has made a mockery of the proceedings.
“Clearly, he distanced himself from the RTC’s coercive processes and trivialized the proceedings with his non-appearance during hearings, and even made a mockery of this Court in seeking relief while in the United States of America, which is clearly a continuing violation of the conditions of his bail,” it added.