The Supreme Court (SC) has sent the Italian remittance arm of Banco de Oro (BDO) back to square one in its bid to cancel the passport of a Filipina worker convicted by a Turin court for misappropriation.
In a recent 7-page decision, the SC 1st Division voided the Mandaluyong City Regional Trial Court (RTC) Branch 212’s September 14, 2009 ruling granting the petition for recognition of foreign judgment filed by BDO Remittance (Italia) S.P.A. against remittance worker Helen Ocampo.
The nullified RTC ruling recognized as valid and binding the Court of Turin’s April 13, 2005 ruling meting out a suspended six-month sentence and a €300 fine after finding her guilty of misappropriating €24,035.60 by falsifying customers’ invoices from February to December 2003.
Thus, the RTC ordered the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) to cancel her Philippine passport and not allow its renewal until she has served her sentence.
But, the SC said the RTC could not take jurisdiction over Ocampo because of the ineffective service of the summons against her.
It said the sheriff’s substituted service on her uncle was improper because her family’s old residence in Tanauan City, Batangas, was no longer her “current residence or office/regular place of business.”
The SC noted that BDO could instead avail of the modes of summons by publication and extraterritorial service, upon the court’s permission.
“The service of summons is a vital and indispensable ingredient of a defendant’s constitutional right to due process. As a rule, if a defendant has not been validly summoned, the court acquires no jurisdiction over his person, and a judgment rendered against him is void,” reminded the decision penned by Associate Justice Francis H. Jardeleza.
But, the SC did not rule out the possibility of the case going on, as it noted the merits of the case can still be resolved by the trial court “upon acquiring jurisdiction over Ocampo and giving her an opportunity to be heard.”