The Sandiganbayan has upheld the graft conviction of a barangay chair and treasure in Ifugao who were found guilty of awarding a power boat supply contract to the village chief’s sister.
The Sandiganbayan denied the appeal of Barangay Dulao chairman Roy Hunnob and treasurer Salvador Galeon that sought to overturn the decision of the Ifugao Regional Trial Court Branch that sentenced them to six to nine years’ imprisonment in 2017 for violation of the anti-graft law.
“Familial bias has always been prevalent in our Filipino culture. On many occasions, the scales of preference had shifted in favor of a family member or ‘kamag-anak,’ often sacrificing merit or due process. The anti-graft law, however, does not permit such bias to seep into our government processes,” the Sandiganbayan Seventh Division said in its November 24, 2023 decision.
The Ifugao RTC had found Hunnob and Galeon liable for awarding a supply contract for a boat engine to Hunnob’s sister Caroline and paying her P67,200.
The Sandigabayan upheld the finding, saying that Hunnob and Galeon approved the procurement and the payment to the supposed supplier despite a failed public bidding.
It also pointed out that the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees restricts transactions between an official and his kin.
“What happened in this case is the very evil the law sought to avoid,” it said.
“Despite a failed public bid, assuming one was indeed made in the first place, the fact that the contract was eventually awarded to the sister of the barangay captain, who had control over the procurement process as head of the procuring entity, spells nothing but suspicion of favoritism and anomalies in the execution of public contracts,” it added.
It noted that the barangay officials, instead of disqualifying the barangay chair’s sister, awarded the contract to her.
“This was a blatant disregard of the law and legal processes in favor of his sister — clear badges of manifest partiality and evident bad faith,” it said.
The state auditor had disallowed the transaction because the procurement documents stated that a 25 horse power speedboat was purchased, but what was delivered was a used boat engine.
The disallowance was settled when the P70,000 was paid back to the barangay.
But the Sandiganbayan said this does not remove the barangay officials’ criminal liability.